The Thinking 
Page 1 of 11

If America Is Gone, Dissidence Is Impossible

November 15, 2012


NUMEROUS comments have been added to the excellent discussion in the entry on whether American traditionalists can rightfully view themselves as dissidents similar to the Soviet dissidents who fought Communism. In that entry, Henry McCulloch writes:

I agree with [Lawrence] Auster that American traditionalists (Americans, in this comment) can no longer dissent from the U.S.A. in the same way Solzhenitsyn dissented from the USSR, although Americans’ view of the U.S. government should parallel Solzhenitsyn’s view of the Soviet Communist Party.  Americans traditionally do not dissociate their country from its government, despite early Americans’ wariness of government.  Solzhenitsyn, by the time he emerged from the gulag, certainly dissociated Russia from the Soviet Union; indeed he viewed the Bolshevik Revolution and all its works as largely alien irruptions into Russian life.  In his mind, Russia and the Communists’ Soviet Union were not at all the same thing.  Solzhenitsyn was right about that, even as he was also right not to deny Russians’ complicity in Communist crimes.

Any successful future in post-America for Americans will be despite the U.S. government, which is as anti-American as the Bolsheviks were anti-Russian.  Mr. Auster says it’s no longer enough to be a dissident, because dissenting implies one seeks the restoration of a previous order.  But no restoration of the old American order is possible.  That America is gone.  Thus the United States that was the legitimate government of America is also gone, succeeded by a U.S. government actively hostile to most Americans.  This is not quite the situation Solzhenitsyn thought Russia was in under Communist rule.  If Solzhenitsyn had believed the Russia buried under the rubble — to borrow a Solzhenitsyn title – of Communism was dead, his life’s work would have been meaningless.

Mr. McCulloch’s comment continues in that entry.


Is There Hope for the GOP?

November 15, 2012


ANDY writes:

There has been a lot of grief and apocalyptic disavowal of the GOP since Romney’s defeat. But the death knell is premature. The GOP can be saved. It is not too late. In short, Romney was a failure as a candidate. He refused to address the issues that mean the most to the white working class. But that’s no surprise because the party has abandoned its grass roots and is run by open borders, free trade plutocrats. Working-class whites saw through this and that’s a major reason why 12 million fewer people voted than in 2008.

We must win the party back. There are solutions to our problems and the Democrats aren’t going to offer them. By defending these solutions, the GOP can appeal to disaffected whites and even liberals. I’m not saying it’s going to be easy. We’re like the Tibetans under the Chinese. But we can unite white America around its own interests and the greater welfare of this nation.  The demographic obstacles can be overcome.

Here are the major issues:

Read More »

Page 1 of 11